Business Help
 
Forums: » Register « |  User CP |  Games |  Calendar |  Members |  FAQs |  Sitemap |  Support | 
User Name:
Password:
Remember me

The Shed is going Social! Join us on FaceBook and Twitter and chime in on the conversation.

Go Back   Dev Shed ForumsWeb Site ManagementBusiness Help

Reply
Add This Thread To:
  Del.icio.us   Digg   Google   Spurl   Blink   Furl   Simpy   Y! MyWeb 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Rate Thread Display Modes
 
Unread Dev Shed Forums Sponsor:
  #1  
Old February 8th, 2005, 07:08 PM
sneaky pete sneaky pete is offline
Registered User
Dev Shed Newbie (0 - 499 posts)
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 7 sneaky pete User rank is Just a Lowly Private (1 - 20 Reputation Level) 
Time spent in forums: 42 m 51 sec
Reputation Power: 0
Pirated Proposal

Here goes.

Three weeks ago I approached a company about a possible website redesign. They were happy to listen, but I was told to come back in a week and outline my idea for improvements.

One week passed. I made a informal presentation to the two owners. They liked my ideas but wanted time to work out a little cost/benefit analysis. "Call back in a few days" they said.

A few days later: "nope, we're not interested right now." No problem. Anyone who builds websites is familiar with a little rejection now and then.

Yesterday I had to call the guys back because they requested some information from me. I forgot their phone number so I went to their website and wouldn't you know it, someone had started to rebuild their website. Worst of all, they're using my proposal ideas!

I'm familiar with copyright laws and of course I've got written proof they're using my ideas but what can I do about this and is it really worth legal action.

I'd be interested in knowing how other people have handled this situation.

Thanks

sp

Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old February 8th, 2005, 07:24 PM
medialint's Avatar
medialint medialint is offline
Type Cast Exception
Dev Shed God 20th Plane (14500 - 14999 posts)
 
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: OAKLAND CA | Adam's Point (Fairyland)
Posts: 14,938 medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)  Folding Points: 319635 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1Folding Points: 319635 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1Folding Points: 319635 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1Folding Points: 319635 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1Folding Points: 319635 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1Folding Points: 319635 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1
Time spent in forums: 6 Months 2 Weeks 2 Days 26 m 49 sec
Reputation Power: 8490
Facebook
You didn't file a copyright so proving anything is, in practice, next to impossible without the filing number in hand.

You can't copyright an idea.

You can patent an idea.

I assume you did not file for a patent.

Conclusion: you have no basis for legal action.

--- edit/continued --

Beyond this basic set of facts regarding copyright and patent, I don't see how you could see any "piracy" of a proposal. A proposal is: I propose that I perform tasks x, y and z and you pay me $n

Next person: I propose that I too will do x, y and z but you only pay me $n*3/5

That's the way proposals and contracts work. I fail to see how there can be any intellectual property involved in a proposal. If there was, next time sign the contract before you start consulting
__________________
medialint.com

“Today you are You, that is truer than true. There is no one alive who is Youer than You.” - Dr. Seuss

Last edited by medialint : February 8th, 2005 at 07:31 PM.

Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old February 8th, 2005, 08:24 PM
sneaky pete sneaky pete is offline
Registered User
Dev Shed Newbie (0 - 499 posts)
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 7 sneaky pete User rank is Just a Lowly Private (1 - 20 Reputation Level) 
Time spent in forums: 42 m 51 sec
Reputation Power: 0
Thanks. Pardon my tone, but I'm a little steamed at the moment.

This is just a follow up to your response.

The below paragraph is from http://www.rightsforartists.com/copyright.html

"While registering for copyright is not required, the legal registration with the Office of Copyright will benefit the copyright owner should an issue of infringement occur. Registering copyright is beneficial because you cannot sue for copyright infringement without registration."

So yes, you're right. I really have no chance at legal recourse. Yet, the above definition does suggest I have limited intellectual property rights--although it would be a long battle proving this and I would never be compensated.

I did develop the idea and whether or not you wish to call this "piracy" or an extreme form of generosity the fact (you'll have to take my word for this. let's not involve the courts) is this idea was stolen from me.

If I followed copyright law (and your suggestions) I would have to patent/copyright my idea months (the link above suggests it could take 8 months) in advance of a client proposal and make any potential client sign a intellectual property rights agreement after I shake their hand. That would go over well.

As the storied saying goes: "Don't hate the player. Hate the game."

Thanks medialint

I hope some this will help someone someday.

sp

Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old February 8th, 2005, 11:29 PM
medialint's Avatar
medialint medialint is offline
Type Cast Exception
Dev Shed God 20th Plane (14500 - 14999 posts)
 
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: OAKLAND CA | Adam's Point (Fairyland)
Posts: 14,938 medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)medialint User rank is General 112nd Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)  Folding Points: 319635 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1Folding Points: 319635 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1Folding Points: 319635 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1Folding Points: 319635 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1Folding Points: 319635 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1Folding Points: 319635 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1
Time spent in forums: 6 Months 2 Weeks 2 Days 26 m 49 sec
Reputation Power: 8490
Facebook
I think you're misunderstanding the whole thing. Look, you're doing work for hire. The end product of that work is the property of your client, not you. If you have an original idea, put together a prototype and copyright that code and, if the idea is so unique, get a patent attorney. You can't copyright an idea. You can only copyright the end product of that idea. "I'm going to write a song about greed and corruption in modern society" is an idea. You can't do anything with that. Whereas the song "Money is not our God" by Killing Joke is the implementation of such an idea. That is where the copyright comes in. If there was a melody or any part of that end product that is distinctive that's where any plagiarism comes in. Not piracy, in any event.

In the corporate world there are vendors that bid for large projects. Each has their proposal. The company tells each what they must have, would like, and what would be nice. Each vendor comes back with an estimate and a list of what can and cannot be done, often accompanied by a mock-up demonstration of the expected result.

Undoubtedly your proposal in turn was created out of your client's need. It should have been. If it wasn't clear that you compete for clients with many other people, it probably is now. Please re-evaluate the situation and see if this isn't true.

Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old March 3rd, 2009, 04:10 PM
colin104 colin104 is offline
Registered User
Dev Shed Newbie (0 - 499 posts)
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 5 colin104 User rank is Just a Lowly Private (1 - 20 Reputation Level) 
Time spent in forums: 2 h 7 m 21 sec
Reputation Power: 0
I think you should have signed a mutual NDA before you revealed your idea to the company. It is not a full guarantee, but at least they would think twice before pirating your idea.

Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old March 3rd, 2009, 04:45 PM
hiker's Avatar
hiker hiker is offline
They're coming to take me away
Dev Shed God (5000 - 5499 posts)
 
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Florida
Posts: 5,091 hiker User rank is General 61st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)hiker User rank is General 61st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)hiker User rank is General 61st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)hiker User rank is General 61st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)hiker User rank is General 61st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)hiker User rank is General 61st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)hiker User rank is General 61st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)hiker User rank is General 61st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)hiker User rank is General 61st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)hiker User rank is General 61st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)hiker User rank is General 61st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)hiker User rank is General 61st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)hiker User rank is General 61st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)hiker User rank is General 61st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)hiker User rank is General 61st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)hiker User rank is General 61st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)  Folding Points: 33832 Folding Title: Starter FolderFolding Points: 33832 Folding Title: Starter Folder
Time spent in forums: 3 Months 2 Weeks 6 Days 21 h 57 m 49 sec
Reputation Power: 5048
Quote:
Originally Posted by colin104
I think you should have signed a mutual NDA before you revealed your idea to the company. It is not a full guarantee, but at least they would think twice before pirating your idea.


I think the original OP has figured out a solution to his problem after 4 years.

Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old March 4th, 2009, 06:13 AM
colin104 colin104 is offline
Registered User
Dev Shed Newbie (0 - 499 posts)
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 5 colin104 User rank is Just a Lowly Private (1 - 20 Reputation Level) 
Time spent in forums: 2 h 7 m 21 sec
Reputation Power: 0
Hiker, I'm not sure what you mean...

Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old March 4th, 2009, 07:10 AM
Axweildr's Avatar
Axweildr Axweildr is offline
'fie' on me, allege-dly
Click here for more information.
 
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: in da kitchen ...
Posts: 12,874 Axweildr User rank is General 81st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)Axweildr User rank is General 81st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)Axweildr User rank is General 81st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)Axweildr User rank is General 81st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)Axweildr User rank is General 81st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)Axweildr User rank is General 81st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)Axweildr User rank is General 81st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)Axweildr User rank is General 81st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)Axweildr User rank is General 81st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)Axweildr User rank is General 81st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)Axweildr User rank is General 81st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)Axweildr User rank is General 81st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)Axweildr User rank is General 81st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)Axweildr User rank is General 81st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)Axweildr User rank is General 81st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)Axweildr User rank is General 81st Grade (Above 100000 Reputation Level)  Folding Points: 162285 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1Folding Points: 162285 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1Folding Points: 162285 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1Folding Points: 162285 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1Folding Points: 162285 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1Folding Points: 162285 Folding Title: Super Ultimate Folder - Level 1
Time spent in forums: 4 Months 2 Weeks 1 Day 20 h 28 m 56 sec
Reputation Power: 6421
Send a message via Google Talk to Axweildr
Orkut
Colin, check the date of the original post ...
Comments on this post
Skipt agrees: We need to get grin here to "explain"...
__________________
--Ax
without exception, there is no rule ...
Handmade Irish Jewellery
Targeted Advertising Cookie Optout (TACO) extension for Firefox
The great thing about Object Oriented code is that it can make small, simple problems look like large, complex ones


09 F9 11 02
9D 74 E3 5B
D8 41 56 C5
63 56 88 C0
Some people, when confronted with a problem, think "I know, I'll use regular expressions." Now they have two problems.
-- Jamie Zawinski
Detavil - the devil is in the detail, allegedly, and I use the term advisedly, allegedly ... oh, no, wait I did ...
BIT COINS ANYONE

Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old March 6th, 2009, 07:02 AM
colin104 colin104 is offline
Registered User
Dev Shed Newbie (0 - 499 posts)
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 5 colin104 User rank is Just a Lowly Private (1 - 20 Reputation Level) 
Time spent in forums: 2 h 7 m 21 sec
Reputation Power: 0
ooooops......
sorry, my mistake

Reply With Quote
Reply

Viewing: Dev Shed ForumsWeb Site ManagementBusiness Help > Pirated Proposal

Developer Shed Advertisers and Affiliates



Thread Tools  Search this Thread 
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes  Rate This Thread 
Rate This Thread:


Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
View Your Warnings | New Posts | Latest News | Latest Threads | Shoutbox
Forum Jump

Forums: » Register « |  User CP |  Games |  Calendar |  Members |  FAQs |  Sitemap |  Support | 
  
 


Powered by: vBulletin Version 3.0.5
Copyright ©2000 - 2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.

© 2003-2013 by Developer Shed. All rights reserved. DS Cluster - Follow our Sitemap