July 25th, 2011, 08:05 AM
I have inherited a network that was partially complete.
The DNS was already setup.
I have a router at my location with an internal IP schema....lets say 10.10.10.0.
My connection to the outside world goes through a circuit to another router at another location. This router broadcasts my network with a different IP Schema...lets say 18.104.22.168.
When I send an email to a specific entity, they are using rDNS. My emails get quarantined because my rDNS response does not return correctly.....actually no name is returned for the IP address.
How do I go in on my DNS server and address this IP address that is broadcasted by the router (the 22.214.171.124 IP). That is what the recipient system is seeing. Can I put a pointer record in my dns for this?
Thanks for any and all assistance.
July 25th, 2011, 08:26 AM
It's doubtful you are authoritative for your reverse. This is usually the ISP's area and they don't like delegating it out. Contact your ISP first and see if they can set one up. If they say it's delegated to you, you'll need to set up a zone for it in the DNS server.
July 25th, 2011, 08:50 AM
This is not through an ISP. It is on a GOV network. I am told I am authoritative. I have not control/access to router broadcasting external IP. So if I set up a zone on my DNS server, do I just setup the pointer or a complete zone with pointer or alias to the internal? I am learning DNS as I go....and like I said...I was handed this network that was partially completed and what was done was not necessarily correct. So I am working through it.
Originally Posted by CaptPikel
Thanks for the assistance.
July 25th, 2011, 10:50 AM
It will need to be entered in whatever you have been delegated. I'm assuming the zone is 212.27.218.in-addr.arpa, but you'd need to double check that. That is where you would create the PTR record. PTR records won't load in a zone like example.com since it would be considered out of zone data. You might be able to do it playing around with $ORIGIN, I've never tried that actually. But I'd recommend it's own specific zone.
I don't know if you're using Windows or BIND(hopefully BIND), but the below relative articles should help in setting it up.
July 25th, 2011, 11:33 AM
Unfortunately it is Windows...not by choice.
Originally Posted by CaptPikel
I will check out the articles provided and get back.
July 25th, 2011, 02:07 PM
OK....I went through the articles....a lot of good information.
Originally Posted by MikeEller
But I think my issue is somewhat different. My DNS server is setup on and for my internal network (10.10.10.0) To the outside world, I look like 212.27.218.x. So how/where in my DNS do I put an entry? Do I create a forward lookup zone for this? And then a reverse lookup zone? or just a reverse zone?
Locations I am sending emails to that are getting blocked say they error saying no rdns for 212.27.218.x. So I am at a loss on how to address this within the DNS I can control.
July 25th, 2011, 02:37 PM
Zones are zones. Forward lookups and reverse lookups follow the same resolution process(start at the top and follow the hints). Personally I don't think about them as being different lookup methods. A DNS lookup is simply what is happening.
The domain name where the PTR resides would be something like 212.27.218.in-addr.arpa and formatted something like this (at least in BIND...):
All the PTR records in the zone are doing is pointing to canonical names. In the point of a mail server, you usually want the IP and FQDN to resolve to each other(better understood as saying the forward and reverse mirror eachother). Knowing Microsoft, there may be something weird you have to do or they may have it worded poorly but I haven't touched a Microsoft server in years so I'm not sure. That Microsoft article looks to explain it but I have no way to check on it.
212.27.218.in-addr.arpa IN SOA ns1.yourserver.com. admin.yourserver.com. (
212.27.218.in-addr.arpa. IN NS ns1.yourserver.com.
212.27.218.in-addr.arpa. IN NS ns2.yourserver.com.
1 IN PTR www.yourserver.com.
2 IN PTR test.yourserver.com.
54 IN PTR mail.yourserver.com.
0 IN PTR ftp.yourserver.com.