October 10th, 2002, 11:16 AM
Choosing a Container or App-Server
I'm in the process of learning server-side Java, and am wondering what container/engine or app server to use.
I ultimately want to make this my profession, and will soon want to build a personal site with this technology. (after reading & learning a bit more...Java's Server-Side platform is quite extensive..there's A LOT to know)
Points to consider:
- Every book I pick up uses Tomcat, and appears to be common place with hosts who offer jsp
- Resin is suppose to be very good (fast),
- I have JRun up and running, but do I want to learn it?
- WebSphere is highly desired in the job market.
- WebLogic is also nice, but may require me purchasing another book..(I'm not that into reading online..unless it's a pdf)
- I will be applying the Model 2 design pattern...this should't affect the decision process, but should be noted.
What do you think??
October 10th, 2002, 03:37 PM
I've used Tomcat and Websphere, and my preference from the two is Tomcat.
I have heard that resin is supposed to be the fastest.
The important thing when you're starting out is to use something that's easy and simple. I started with Orion, since I couldn't figure out Tomcat (Tomcat 4.1 is a WHOLE lot easier to use, though).
Once you're up to speed and feel comfortable with the environment, try out a few servers, get a feel for their strengths/weaknesses, find the ones you like. I think you'll find that they're all fairly similar from a developer's standpoint.
October 14th, 2002, 10:04 PM
Ok.. I'm a novice here..
WHat is the different between J2EE and Tomcat ? I'm using Tomcat now but heard that J2EE is similar...
And I had heard a lot of J-Serv and Mod_jk ... Are they the same ?
October 14th, 2002, 10:31 PM
J2EE is a specification from Sun. It includes servlets, jsps, ejbs, and other "Enterprise" java stuff.
Tomcat is an application server. It lets you run J2EE applications.
JServ is a servlet engine. It runs servlets.
Mod_jk is a replacement for mod_jserv that allows Apache and Tomcat to talk to each other.
October 14th, 2002, 10:53 PM
"Mod_jk is a replacement for mod_jserv that allows Apache and Tomcat to talk to each other."
if you'd like the familiarity of apache then you can use apache to handle your non-java content (html, gif, php etc) and use mod_jk to pass requests for jsp pages off to tomcat. however, tomcat can function on it's own as a webserver for non-java content, so setting up mod_jk at this stage may be unecessary work.
i believe that the apache project intends to make mod_jk act as a connector for more webservers than just apache, though i don't remember whether this has been implemented yet. if you use a connector, mod_jk should be chosen over mod_jserv (as it has a future, by the sound of things).
my advice, if you're just starting out on this stuff: install tomcat and rest there - you can always connect it into apache when you are more familiar with what's going on.
Little more than a playground for the bugs that live beneath us...
October 14th, 2002, 10:59 PM
I guess I just leave it with Tomcat for the time being ..