[LAYOUT] Review my "Mockups" please. I need to pick one asap!

The problem is that I like all of these but I did cut down to these 3 out of 8 mockups. Now your help is needed

Links:

http://smack3.com/images/sites/mock2.jpg

http://smack3.com/images/sites/mock4.jpg

http://smack3.com/images/sites/mock5.jpg

Maybe think in terms of which site would you enjoy using.

My Pick: I like mock2 because it's clean and has a modern feel

I like mock4 because the header area is nice and I have plenty of room above the fold for content, and it allows the user to focus on searching.

Mock5 is great because like mock4 the header area is great. Only I think that makes it better in functionality is the fact that Categories, Breadcrumbs and Search are all placed well making the primary navigational focus of this site perfect.

FYI, this site is for designers of logos, stationary, etc to sell their items on our marketplace. That might help decide.



PS. I need to pick the one that has the best design, is the most functional, usable and straight forward.

Thanks everyone

well the choice is between the first one and the other two because they are pretty much the same. but id go for http://smack3.com/images/sites/mock4.jpg. nothing against the first one but the buttons are slightly big. now imagine what would happen if someone who has a smaller screen and resolution visits the site.... GIGANTIC BUTTONS is where he'll be at